Costco lawsuit alert: A California woman sues Costco for $14 million, alleging a falling display caused life-altering injuries. Learn about the negligence claims and legal case details.
What is the Costco Lawsuit About?
A high-stakes Costco lawsuit is unfolding after Sadie Novotny, a California woman, filed a claim for $14 million in damages following a traumatic injury at a Santa Rosa Costco. The suit alleges the retail giant was negligent in managing its store merchandise, resulting in a display cabinet falling on her without warning.
Incident That Sparked the Costco Lawsuit
On March 22, 2024, Novotny was shopping with her husband when a heavy liquor cabinet display reportedly toppled over and landed on her. Despite catching part of the cabinet to reduce the blow, Novotny immediately experienced pain in her right shoulder, hand, back, and head. The incident eventually led to a diagnosis of a traumatic brain injury and permanent physical damage.
Also Read: Denzel Clarke-Rising MLB Star with Big League Dreams
Costco Lawsuit Alleges Multiple Types of Negligence
Novotny’s legal filing accuses Costco of violating several key legal responsibilities, which form the foundation of her lawsuit:
General Negligence
The Costco lawsuit claims store staff failed to secure the liquor cabinet, allowing it to stand on thin legs and a worn pallet—creating a clear risk.
Premises Liability
This is where property owners are held responsible for hazardous conditions. The lawsuit claims Costco did not ensure the store was safe for its customers.
Product Liability
The case also involves product liability, suggesting the cabinet may have been defectively designed or inappropriately displayed, both contributing factors to the accident.
Damages Sought in the Costco Lawsuit
Novotny is asking for $14.11 million in damages to cover:
-
$5 million – Emotional distress
-
$5 million – Pain, suffering, and inconvenience
-
$2 million – Estimated future medical costs
-
$2 million – Loss of earning capacity
-
$50,000 – Current medical bills
-
$50,000 – Lost income so far
-
$10,000 – Loss of household services
Official Costco Incident Report Adds Credibility
The lawsuit includes an incident report filed by Costco at the time of the accident. Novotny reportedly attempted to prevent the cabinet from falling but was overwhelmed by the weight. Costco has not yet responded to public requests for comment, including from USA TODAY.
Also Read: Bay area woman sues Costco for $14 million after cabinet display collapse causes brain injury
Costco Lawsuit Moves to Federal Court
The Costco lawsuit, initially filed in California Superior Court for Alameda County, has now been transferred to U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California as of June 5, 2025.
Legal experts suggest this move might work in Costco’s favor, as federal courts often have stricter procedures, which could delay proceedings or even result in summary judgments if the evidence is weak.
Why This Costco Lawsuit Matters
Retailers like Costco are legally obligated to maintain safe shopping environments. This case raises questions about store safety standards, employee training, and the proper display of merchandise. A win for Novotny could encourage stricter retail compliance across the U.S.
Costco Lawsuit Highlights Safety and Responsibility
The Costco lawsuit filed by Sadie Novotny is more than a demand for compensation—it’s a reminder of the importance of corporate accountability. As legal proceedings continue, the case may set a new benchmark for how retail environments must manage safety risks.